One True Loves Read online

  Marie isn’t much of a crier. She isn’t one to show how she feels on her face. It’s her voice that tells me just how deep her remorse is, the way some of the syllables bubble up and burst.

  “I was the wrong person to be up there that day. I hadn’t supported you, at all, really, in any of the years prior. And suddenly, I was the one telling you the worst had happened? I just . . . I thought he was gone. And I thought that I was doing you a kindness by making you face reality.” She shakes her head as if disappointed in her old self. “But instead, what I did was take away your hope. Hope that you had every reason to hold on to. And I . . . I’m just very sorry. I’m deeply sorry. You have no idea how much I regret taking that away from you.”

  “No,” I say. “That’s not what happened. Not at all. I was crazy up on that roof. I’d gone absolutely crazy, Marie. It was irrational to think that he was alive, let alone that I could save him, that I could spot him up there, looking at that tiny piece of the shore. That was madness.

  “Anyone thinking clearly would have made the assumption that he was dead. I needed to understand that the rational conclusion was that he was gone. You helped me understand that. You kept me sane.”

  For the first time, I find myself wondering if facing the truth and being sane aren’t the same thing, if they are just two things that tend to go together. I’m starting to understand that they might be correlational rather than synonyms.

  And then I realize that if I don’t blame Marie for thinking he was dead—if I don’t see her belief that he died as a sign she gave up on him—then I shouldn’t be blaming myself for doing the same thing.

  “Please don’t give it another thought,” I say to her. “What you did on the roof that day . . . you saved me.”

  Marie looks down at her tea and then nods. “Thank you for saying that.”

  “Thank you for what you did. And I’m glad it was you. I don’t know if you and I would be as close . . . I mean, I think we would have just gone on . . .”

  “I know what you mean,” Marie said. “I know.”

  After all of our shared experiences and our parents’ cajoling, it has been our hardships that have softened us to each other. Losing my husband and the challenges of raising Marie’s twins are the things that have brought us together.

  “I’m just glad that things between us are the way they are now,” Marie says. “I’m very, very glad.”

  “Me, too,” I say.

  Instinctively, I grab Marie’s hand and hold it for a moment and then we break away.

  It is hard to be so honest, so vulnerable, so exposed. But I find that it always leads you someplace freer. I feel the smallest shift between my sister and me, something almost imperceptible but nevertheless real. We are closer now than we were just three minutes ago.

  “I’ve been thinking about writing again,” Marie says, changing the subject.

  “Oh yeah?” I ask. “Writing what?”

  She shrugs. “That’s the part I’m not sure about. I just need to do something, you know? Anything that is not revolving around my kids. I need to get back to me, a little bit. Anyway, it might be a dumb idea because I say that I want to start writing again but I can’t find anything I want to write about. I’m not inspired. I’m just . . . well, bored.”

  “You’ll find something,” I say. “And when you do, it will be great. Just don’t make it a murder mystery where you pin the murders on a character that is clearly supposed to be me, like you did back then,” I say, teasing.

  She laughs, shaking her head at me. “No one ever believed me that it wasn’t supposed to be you,” she says.

  “You named her Emily.”

  “It’s a common name,” Marie says, pretending to defend herself. “But, yeah, OK. I’m mature enough now to admit that might not have come from a totally innocent place.”

  “Thank you,” I say magnanimously.

  “I was just so annoyed that you were always copying me.”

  “What?” I say. “I was never copying you. I was basically the opposite of you.”

  Marie shakes her head. “Sorry, but no. Remember when I got really into TLC? And suddenly, you started telling everyone you loved ‘Waterfalls’? Or when I had a crush on Keanu Reeves? And then suddenly, you had his picture up over your bed?”

  “Oh, my God,” I say, realizing she’s totally right.

  “And then, of course, you went and started dating the captain of the swim team. Just like me.”

  “Whoa,” I say. “That honestly never occurred to me. But you’re totally right. You and Graham. And then me and Jesse.”

  Marie smiles, half laughing at me. “See?”

  “I must have really wanted to be like you,” I say. “Because I thought Graham was so lame. And then I went and also dated the captain of the swim team.”

  Marie lifts her tea to her mouth, smiling. “So, I think we can agree that on some level, you’ve always wanted to be me.”

  I laugh. “You know what? If being you means having just the one man in your life, I’ll take it.”

  “Boohoo,” she says. “Two men love you.”

  “Oh, shut up,” I say as I find a dish towel and throw it at her.

  Our laughter is interrupted by Mike coming down the stairs with Sophie behind him and Ava on his hip.

  “Breakfast!” he says to the girls, and I see Marie reanimate, opening up the refrigerator, ready for the day.

  I know when to excuse myself.

  “I’m around if you need anything today,” Marie says as I gather my things. “Seriously. Just call. Or stop by. I’m here for you.”

  “OK,” I say. “Thank you.”

  She gives me a hug and then picks up Sophie into her arms. I head out the door.

  On the way back to my parents’, my phone dings. I’m not sure who I thought would be contacting me but I definitely wasn’t expecting a text message from Francine.

  So excited to see you again that I didn’t sleep all night. This is Jesse, btw. Not my mom. Pretty weird if my mom couldn’t wait to see you.

  When I’m done reading it, I notice that my feet walk faster toward the door to my parents’ house.

  I rush my warm shower. I rush the shampoo through my hair, rush the soap over my body.

  I rush putting on clothes and getting out the door.

  I rush all of it, every second. There is a kick in my step and a smile on my face.

  I am happy. In this brief moment of time. I am happy.

  When I pull my car into the parking lot of Julie’s Place a little before seven thirty, Jesse is standing right in front. He’s even earlier than I am.

  He looks just like he used to, even if he does look totally different.

  I open my car door, step out into the cold, and I realize just why this morning feels a little bit better than the others recently.

  It’s finally OK to love him.

  It’s OK to love Jesse.

  I have been given the freedom to do that.

  Sam did that for me.

  What else did you miss?” I ask Jesse as the waitress brings us our breakfasts. He’s been listing everything he missed about home.

  I was number one.

  The sweet-and-sour chicken at the tacky Chinese restaurant in the middle of town was number two.

  “I mean, there are so many people and places, but right now, honestly, all I can think about is the food.”

  I laugh. “So tell me, then; tell me all the food.”

  “All right,” he says, looking down at his plate. He has barely touched his meal and I can’t blame him. I can’t focus on actually eating right now, either. My stomach is in knots, flooded with butterflies, twisting and turning to try to keep up with the flutter in my heart.

  “Oh, God. There are just too many to name. How can I choose? I mean, there’s the pizza at Sorrentos, the Snickers sundae from Friendly’s, the sandwiches at Savory Lane . . .”

  “Savory Lane closed,” I tell him. “Actually, Friendly’s did, too.”

/>   He looks at me, focused on my eyes, trying to figure out if I’m messing with him. When he sees that I’m serious, a flash of sorrow wipes across his face. He quickly replaces it with a smile, but I wonder if maybe it’s all the evidence he needs that the world went on without him, that we couldn’t even keep Savory Lane going as a courtesy.

  “Friendly’s is now a Johnny Rockets,” I tell him. “It’s good, though. Plus, you know, once Kimball’s opens in the spring, you’re not going to be thinking about a Snickers sundae. You’re gonna be thinking about two scoops of black raspberry ice cream in a waffle cone.”

  Jesse smiles and then looks away from me, shifting his body toward the counter and away from our table, repositioning his legs. “What about Erickson’s? Is that still open? Or have they forsaken me, too?”

  The way he says it, the word “forsaken,” and the fact that he doesn’t look at me, it all adds up to make me think Jesse’s angrier than he’s letting on. That he does resent me for moving on. He says he understands, but maybe he doesn’t really understand at all.

  “They are still open, yeah,” I say, nodding, trying to please him. “Most stuff is still open. Most stuff is still the same.”

  “Most stuff,” he says, and then he changes his tone. “And Blair Books? Is Blair Books the same? I mean, clearly there’s new management.”

  “Yeah,” I say, smiling, proud of myself. “Although I’ve kept it mostly the same. And my parents are still involved a bit. It’s not like I’ve gone rogue. I do things pretty much the way they did them.”

  “Do you even put out those little ‘Travel the World by Reading a Book’ bookmarks?”

  “Yes!” I say. “Of course I do.”

  “What? No way!”

  “Yeah, totally.”

  I have pushed the food around my plate. He’s pushed his around his. Neither one of us has taken so much as a bite. When the waitress comes over, she frowns.

  “Looks like you aren’t very hungry,” she says as she pours more water in my glass.

  “It’s delicious,” I say. “But we’re just . . .”

  “We have a lot of catching up to do,” Jesse says. “Can we get it to go?”

  “Sure thing, sweetheart,” she says, taking both of our plates with her.

  When she leaves, we have no food to play with and nothing to look at but each other.

  “You used to hate those bookmarks,” Jesse says.

  “I know,” I say. I find myself embarrassed about how much I’ve changed. I am tempted to lie, to rewind, to remember exactly who I was before he left and try to be that version of myself again.

  The Emma he knew wanted a different life. She wanted adventure. She ached with wanderlust. She used to think you couldn’t find joy in simple things, that they had to be big and bold and wild. That you couldn’t feel amazed at how good it feels to wake up in a nice bed, that you could only feel amazed by petting elephants and visiting the Louvre.

  But I don’t know if I was totally that person when he left.

  And I’m definitely not that person now.

  The future is so hard to predict. If I had a time machine, would it even make a difference to try to go back there and explain to my young self what was ahead?

  “I guess I did say that,” I tell him. “But I like them now.”

  “You never cease to surprise,” Jesse says, smiling. Maybe it’s OK with him if I’m not exactly the way I was when he left.

  The waitress comes back with our meals in boxes and the check. Jesse hands her cash before I can grab my wallet.

  “Thank you,” I say. “That was very nice of you.”

  “It’s my pleasure.”

  I check my phone and see that it’s eight fifty. The time has flown by so quickly.

  “I have to head to work,” I tell him. “I’m running late as is.”

  “No . . .” he says. “C’mon. Stay with me.”

  “I can’t,” I say, smiling at him. “I have a store to open.”

  Jesse walks me to my car and pulls a set of keys out of his pocket, unlocking, from afar, a gray sedan a few spaces down.

  “Wait a minute,” I say to Jesse, as something is occurring to me. “You don’t have a license. You can’t be driving.”

  Jesse laughs. “I had a license before I left,” he says. “I’m approved to drive a car.”

  “Yeah,” I say, opening my door. “But didn’t it expire?”

  Jesse smiles mischievously and it slays me. “Expired, schmexpired. It’s harmless.”

  “You just always have to push things, don’t you?” I say, teasing him. “Why do you think that is?”

  “I don’t know,” he says, shrugging. “But you can admit you find it charming.”

  I laugh. “Who said I find it charming?”

  “Will you get in the car with me?” he says.

  “In your car?”

  “Or yours,” he says.

  “I have to go to work.”

  “I know. I’m not asking you to go anywhere with me. I just want to be in the car with you. It’s cold outside.”

  I should tell him good-bye. I’m already running later than I want to be.

  “OK,” I say. I click both doors open and watch as Jesse sits in my passenger seat. I sit in the driver’s seat next to him. When I shut my car door, the outside world mutes, as if we can keep it at bay.

  I watch as his eye line settles on my now-bare ring finger. He smiles. We both know what the empty space on my left hand means. But I get the impression there is a strange code of silence between us, indicative of the two things we don’t talk about. We won’t talk about what happened to my finger, just like we don’t talk about what happened to his.

  “I missed you, Emma. I missed us. I missed your stupid eyes and your awful lips and that super-annoying thing you do when you look at me like I’m the only person that’s ever mattered in the history of the world. I missed your very un-adorable freckles.”

  I laugh and I can feel myself blushing. “I missed you, too.”

  “You did?” he says, as if this is news, as if he wasn’t sure.

  “Wait, are you kidding?”

  “I don’t know,” he says. His voice is teasing. “It’s hard to know what happened while I was gone.”

  “I was more heartbroken than I’ve ever been or I think I will ever be again.”

  He looks at me, and then out the windshield, and then out the window on the other side of him.

  “We have so much to talk about and I don’t even know where to start,” he says.

  “I know, but even if we did know where to start, I can’t now. I have to go to work. I should have been there fifteen minutes ago.” Tina won’t be in until the afternoon. If I’m not there, the store doesn’t open.

  “Emma,” he says, looking at me like I’m a fool. “You’re not going to be at work on time, that’s clear. So what’s a few more minutes? What’s an hour more?”

  I look at him and find myself considering it. And then I feel his lips on mine. They are just as bold and surprising as they were almost fifteen years ago, kissing me for the first time.

  I close my eyes and reach for him. I kiss him again. And again and again and again. I am soothed and invigorated all at once. Never before has something felt so exciting and yet so familiar.

  I lose myself in him, in the way he feels, the way he smells, the way he moves.

  Can you ever put things back the way they were? Can you chalk the intervening years up as a mistake and pick up as if you never left each other?

  I feel Jesse’s hand slide down my arm and then I hear myself accidentally hit the horn with my elbow.

  I snap out of it. I pull myself away from him and look forward, out the windshield. Two of the servers at Julie’s Place, including the woman who waited on us, are staring at us through the window. When they see that I see them, they start to turn away.

  I look down at my phone. It’s almost a quarter of ten. The store is supposed to be open in less than twenty minutes.r />
  “I have to go!” I say, shocked that I could be running this late.

  “OK, OK,” Jesse says, but he doesn’t move.

  “Get out of my car,” I say, laughing.

  “OK,” he says, putting his hand on the door handle. “There’s just one thing I wanted to talk to you about.”

  “Jesse! I have to go!”

  “Come to Maine with me,” he says as he gets out of the car.

  “What?”

  “Come to my family’s cabin in Maine with me for a few days. We can leave tonight. Just the two of us.”

  “I have a store to run.”

  “Your parents can manage it. For a little while. It’s their store.”

  “It’s my store,” I say.

  “Emma, we need time. And not stolen moments before you go to work. Real time. Please.”

  I look at him, considering.

  He knows I’m considering it. Which is why he already starts smiling. “Is that a yes?” he says.

  I know my parents will step in and I’m late and I don’t have time for this.

  “OK, a couple of days.”

  “Three,” he says. “Three days.”

  “OK,” I tell him. “Three.”

  “We’ll leave tonight?”

  “Sure. Now I have to go!”

  Jesse smiles at me and then shuts the door behind him so I can finally leave. He waves at me through the window. I find myself grinning as I drive away from him, leaving him there in the parking lot.

  I make my way to the road and wait for a clear opening to take a left. I watch as Jesse gestures for me to roll down my window from the other side of the lot. I roll my eyes but I do it.

  He cups his hands over his mouth and yells, “I’m sorry I made you late! I love you!”

  I have no choice but to scream, “I love you, too!”

  I bang a left onto the main road and fly through town. I get to the parking lot of Blair Books at ten eleven and I can already see there is a customer waiting at the door.

  I jump out of the car, open the back door, and run through the store turning on all the lights.

  I gather myself and calmly walk to the front door and unlock it.

  “Hi,” I say to the woman waiting.

  “Your store says that you’re open from ten to seven. It’s ten fifteen.”