One True Loves Page 2

  I needed new jeans because I’d worn holes into all of my old ones. I was supposed to get a new pair every Christmas but I was so particular about what I wanted, so neurotic about what I thought they should look like, that my mother had given up. Twice now we had gone to the mall and left after an hour, my mother trying her best to hide her irritation.

  It was a new experience for me. My mother always wanted to be around me, craving my company my entire childhood. But I had finally become so annoying about something that she was willing to pass me off to someone else. And on a Saturday, no less.

  “Who’s going to work the register?” I said. The minute it came out of my mouth, I regretted it. I was suddenly nervous that I’d poked a hole in a good thing. I should have simply said, “Okay,” and backed away slowly, so as to not startle her.

  “The new boy we hired, Sam,” my mom said. “It’s fine. He needs the hours.”

  Sam was a sophomore at school who walked into the store one day and said, “Can I fill out an application?” even though we weren’t technically hiring and most teenagers wanted to work at the CD store down the street. My parents hired him on the spot.

  He was pretty cute—tall and lanky with olive skin and dark brown eyes—and was always in a good mood, but I found myself incapable of liking him once Marie deemed him “adorable.” I couldn’t bring myself to like anything she liked.

  Admittedly, this type of thinking was starting to limit my friend pool considerably and becoming unsustainable.

  Marie liked everyone and everyone liked Marie.

  She was the Golden Child, the one destined to be our parents’ favorite. My friend Olive used to call her “the Booksellers’ Daughter” behind her back because she even seemed like the sort of girl whose parents would own a bookstore, as if there was a very specific stereotype and Marie was tagging off each attribute like a badge of honor.

  She read adult books and wrote poetry and had crushes on fictional characters instead of movie stars and she made Olive and I want to barf.

  When Marie was my age, she took a creative writing elective and decided that she wanted to “become a writer.” The quotation marks are necessary because the only thing she ever wrote was a nine-page murder mystery where the killer turned out to be the protagonist’s little sister, Emily. I read it and even I could tell it was complete garbage, but she submitted it to the school paper and they loved it so much they ran it in installments over the course of nine weeks in the spring semester.

  The fact that she managed to do all of that while still being one of the most popular girls in school made it that much worse. It just goes to show that if you’re pretty enough, cool comes to you.

  I, meanwhile, had covertly read the CliffsNotes in the library for almost every book assigned to us in English 1. I had a pile of novels in my room that my parents had given me as gifts and I had refused to even crack the spines.

  I liked music videos, NBC’s Thursday Must-See TV lineup, and every single woman who performed at Lilith Fair. When I was bored, I would go through my mom’s old issues of Travel + Leisure, tearing out pictures and taping them to my wall. The space above my bed became a kaleidoscope of magazine covers of Keanu Reeves, liner notes from Tori Amos albums, and centerfolds of the Italian Riviera and the French countryside.

  And no one, I repeat no one, would have confused me for a popular kid.

  My parents joked that the nurse must have given them the wrong child at the hospital and I always laughed it off, but I had, more than once, looked at pictures of my parents as children and then stared at myself in the mirror, counting the similarities, reminding myself I belonged to them.

  “Okay, great,” I told my mom, more excited about not having to go to work than spending time with my sister. “When are we leaving?”

  “I don’t know,” my mom said. “Talk to Marie. I’m off to the store. I’ll see you for dinner. I love you, honey. Have a good day.”

  When she shut my door, I lay back down on the bed with vigor, ready to relish every single extra minute of sleep.

  Sometime after eleven, Marie barged into my room and said, “C’mon, we’re leaving.”

  We went to three stores and I tried on twelve pairs of jeans. Some were too baggy, some too tight, some came up too high on my waist.

  I tried on the twelfth pair and came out of the dressing room to see Marie staring at me, bored senseless.

  “They look fine; just get them,” she said. She was wearing head-to-toe Abercrombie & Fitch. It was the turn of the millennium. All of New England was wearing head-to-toe Abercrombie & Fitch.

  “They look weird in the butt,” I said, staying perfectly still.

  Marie stared at me, as if she expected something.

  “Are you gonna turn around so I can see if they are weird in the butt, or what?” she finally said.

  I turned around.

  “They make you look like you’re wearing a diaper,” she told me.

  “That’s what I just said.”

  Marie rolled her eyes. “Hold on.” She circled her finger in the air, indicating that I should go back into the dressing room. And so I did.

  I had just pulled the last pair of jeans off when she threw a pair of faded straight-leg ones over the top of the door.

  “Try these,” she said. “Joelle wears them and she has a big butt like yours.”

  “Thanks a lot,” I said, grabbing the jeans from the door.

  “I’m just trying to help you,” she said, and then I could see her feet walk away, as if the conversation was over simply because she wasn’t interested in it anymore.

  I unzipped the fly and stepped in. I had to shimmy them over my hips and suck in the tiniest bit to get them buttoned. I stood tall and looked at myself in the mirror, posing this way and that, turning my head to check out what I looked like from behind.

  My butt was growing shapelier by the day and my boobs seemed to have stagnated. I had read enough of my mother’s Glamour magazines to know that this was referred to as “pear shaped.” My stomach was flat but my hips were growing. Olive was starting to gain weight in her boobs and her stomach and I wondered if I wouldn’t prefer that sort of figure. Apple shaped.

  But, if I was being honest with myself, what I really wanted was all that my mother had passed on to Marie. Medium butt, medium boobs, brown hair, green eyes, and thick lashes.

  Instead, I got my father’s coloring—hair neither fully blond nor fully brunette, eyes somewhere in between brown and green—with a body type all my own. Once, I asked my mother where I got my short, sturdy legs from and she said, “I don’t know, actually,” as if this wasn’t the worst thing she’d ever said to me.

  There was only one thing about my appearance that I truly loved. My freckles, that cluster of tiny dark spots under my right eye. My mom used to connect the dots with her finger as she put me to bed as a child.

  I loved my freckles and hated my butt.

  So as I stood there in the dressing room, all I wanted was a pair of jeans that made my butt look smaller. Which these seemed to do.

  I stepped out of the dressing room to ask Marie’s opinion. Unfortunately, she was nowhere to be found.

  I stepped back into the dressing room, realizing I had no one to make this decision with but me.

  I looked at myself one more time in the mirror.

  Maybe I liked them?

  I looked at the tag. Thirty-five bucks.

  With tax, I’d still have money left over to get teriyaki chicken from the food court.

  I changed out of them, headed to the register, and handed over my parents’ money. I was rewarded with a bag containing one pair of jeans that I did not hate.

  Marie was still missing.

  I checked around the store. I walked down to the Body Shop to see if she was there buying lip balm or shower gel. Thirty minutes later, I found her buying earrings at Claire’s.

  “I’ve been looking all over for you,” I said.

  “Sorry, I was looking at jewelr
y.” Marie took her change, delicately put it back into her wallet, and then grabbed the tiny white plastic bag that, no doubt, contained fake gold sure to stain her ears a greenish gray.

  I followed Marie as she walked confidently out of the store and toward the entrance where we’d parked.

  “Wait,” I said, stopping in place. “I wanted to go to the food court.”

  Marie turned toward me. She looked at her watch. “Sorry, no can do. We’re gonna be late.”

  “For what?”

  “The swim meet,” she said.

  “What swim meet?” I asked her. “No one said anything about a swim meet.”

  Marie didn’t answer me because she didn’t have to. I was already following her back to the car, already willing to go where she told me to go, willing to do what she told me to do.

  It wasn’t until we got in the car that she deigned to fill me in. “Graham is the captain of the swim team this year,” she said.

  Ah, yes.

  Graham Hughes. Captain of every team he’s on. The frontrunner for “best smile” in the yearbook. Exactly the sort of person Saint Marie of Acton would be dating.

  “Great,” I said. It seemed clear that my future entailed not just sitting and watching the fifty-meter freestyle, but also waiting in Marie’s car afterward while she and Graham made out in his.

  “Can we at least hit a drive-through on the way there?” I asked, already defeated.

  “Yeah, fine,” she said.

  And then I mustered up as much confidence as I possibly could and said, “You’re paying.”

  She turned and laughed at me. “You’re fourteen. You can’t buy your own lunch?”

  She had the most amazing ability to make me feel stupid even at my most self-assured.

  We stopped at a Burger King and I ate a Whopper Jr. in the front seat of her car, getting ketchup and mustard on my hands and having to wait until we parked to find a napkin.

  Marie ditched me the minute we smelled the chlorine in the air. So I sat on the bleachers and did my best to entertain myself.

  The indoor pool was full of barely clothed, physically fit boys my age. I wasn’t sure where to look.

  When Graham got up on the diving block and the whistle blew, I watched as he dove into the water with the ease of a bird flying through the air. From the minute he entered the water, it was clear he was going to win the race.

  I saw Marie, over in the far corner, bouncing up and down, willing him to win, believing in him with all of her might. When Graham claimed his throne, I got up and walked around, past the other side of the bleachers and through the gym, in search of a vending machine.

  When I came back—fifty cents poorer, a bag of Doritos richer—I saw Olive sitting toward the front of the crowd with her family.

  One day last summer, just before school started, Olive and I were hanging out in her basement when she told me that she thought she might be gay.

  She said she wasn’t sure. She just didn’t feel like she was totally straight. She liked boys. But she was starting to think she might like girls.

  I was pretty sure I was the only one who knew. And I was also pretty sure that her parents had begun to suspect. But that wasn’t my business. My only job was to be a friend to her.

  So I did the things friends do, like sit there and watch music videos for hours, waiting for Natalie Imbruglia’s “Torn” video to come on so that Olive could stare at her. This was not an entirely selfless act since it was my favorite song and I dreamt of chopping off my hair to look just like Natalie Imbruglia’s.

  Also not entirely selfless was my willingness to rewatch Titanic every few weeks as Olive tried to figure out if she liked watching the sex scene between Jack and Rose because she was attracted to Leonardo DiCaprio or Kate Winslet.

  “Hey!” she said as I entered her sight line that day at the pool.

  “Hey,” I said back. Olive was wearing a white camisole under an unbuttoned light blue oxford button-down. Her long jet-black hair hung straight and past her shoulders. With a name like Olive Berman, you might not realize she was half-Jewish, half-Korean, but she was proud of where her mother’s family had come from in South Korea and equally proud of how awesome her bat mitzvah was.

  “What are you doing here?” she asked me.

  “Marie dragged me and then ditched me.”

  “Ah,” Olive said, nodding. “Just like the Booksellers’ Daughter. Is she here to see Graham?” Olive made a face when she said Graham’s name and I appreciated that she also found Graham to be laughable.

  “Yeah,” I said. “But . . . wait, why are you here?”

  Olive’s brother swam until he graduated last year. Olive had tried but failed to make the girls’ swim team.

  “My cousin Eli swims for Sudbury.”

  Olive’s mom turned away from the swim meet and looked at me. “Hi, Emma. Come, have a seat.” When I sat down next to Olive, Mrs. Berman turned her focus back to the pool.

  Eli came in third and Mrs. Berman reflexively pumped her hands into frustrated fists and then shook her head. She turned and looked at Olive and me.

  “I’m going to go give Eli a conciliatory hug and then, Olive, we can head home,” she said.

  I wanted to ask if I could join them on their way home. Olive lived only five minutes from me. My house was more or less between theirs and the highway exit. But I had trouble asking things of people. I felt more comfortable skirting around it.

  “I should probably find Marie,” I said. “See if we can head out.”

  “We can take you,” Olive said. “Right, Mom?”

  “Of course,” Mrs. Berman said as she stood up and squeezed through the crowded bleachers. “Do you want to come say good-bye to Eli? Or should I meet you two at the car?”

  “The car,” Olive said. “Tell Eli I said hi, though.”

  Olive put her hand right into my Doritos bag and helped herself.

  “Okay,” she said once her mom was out of earshot. “Did you see the girl on the other side of the pool, talking to that guy in the red Speedo?”

  “Huh?”

  “The girl with the ponytail. Talking to somebody on Eli’s team. I honestly think she might be the hottest girl in the world. Like ever. Like, that has ever existed in all of eternity.”

  I looked toward the pool, scanning for a girl with a ponytail. I came up empty. “Where is she?” I said.

  “Okay, she’s standing by the diving board now,” Olive said as she pointed. “Right there. Next to Jesse Lerner.”

  “Who?” I said as I followed Olive’s finger right to the diving board. And I did, in fact, see a pretty girl with a ponytail. But I did not care.

  Because I also saw the tall, lean, muscular boy next to her.

  His eyes were deep set, his face angular, his lips full. His short, light brown hair, half-matted, half-akimbo, the result of pulling the swimming cap up off his head. I could tell from his swimsuit that he went to our school.

  “Do you see her?” Olive said.

  “Yeah,” I said. “Yeah, she’s pretty. But the guy she’s talking to . . . What did you say his name was?”

  “Who?” Olive asked. “Jesse Lerner?”

  “Yeah. Who is Jesse Lerner?”

  “How do you not know who Jesse Lerner is?”

  I turned and looked at Olive. “I don’t know. I just don’t. Who is he?”

  “He lives down the street from the Hughes.”

  I turned back to Jesse, watching him pick up a pair of goggles off the ground. “Is he in our grade?”

  “Yeah.”

  Olive kept speaking but I had already started to tune her out. Instead, I was watching Jesse as he headed back to the locker room with the rest of his team. Graham was right next to him, putting a hand on his shoulder for a brief moment before jumping ahead of him in the slow line that had formed. I couldn’t take my eyes off of the way Jesse moved, the confidence with which he put one foot in front of the other. He was younger than any of the other swimmers—a f
reshman on the varsity team—and yet seemed right at home, standing in front of everyone in a tiny swimsuit.

  “Emma,” Olive said. “You’re staring.”

  Just then, Jesse turned his head ever so slightly and his gaze landed squarely on me, for a brief, breathless second. Instinctively, I looked away.

  “What did you say?” I asked Olive, trying to pretend I was engaged with her side of the conversation.

  “I said you were staring at him.”

  “No, I wasn’t,” I said.

  It was then that Mrs. Berman came back around to our side of the bleachers. “I thought you were meeting me at the car,” she said.

  “Sorry!” Olive said, jumping up onto her feet. “We’re coming now.”

  “Sorry, Mrs. Berman,” I said, and I followed them both behind the bleachers and out the door.

  I paused, just before the exit, to see Jesse one last time. I saw a flash of his smile. It was wide and bright, toothy and sincere. His whole face lit up.

  I wondered how good it would feel to have that smile directed at me, to be the cause of a smile like that—and suddenly, my new crush on Jesse Lerner grew into a massive, inflated balloon that was so strong it could have lifted the two of us up into the air if we’d grabbed on.

  That week at school, I noticed Jesse in the hallway almost every day. Now that I knew who he was, he was everywhere.

  “That’s the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon,” Olive said when I mentioned it at lunch. “My brother just told me about this. You don’t notice something and then you learn the name for it and suddenly it’s everywhere.” Olive thought for a moment. “Whoa. I’m pretty sure I have the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon about the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon.”

  “Are you seeing Jesse everywhere, too?” I asked, entirely missing the point. Earlier that day, I’d walked right by him coming out of Spanish class. He was talking to Carolyn Bean by her locker. Carolyn Bean was the captain of the girls’ soccer team. She wore her blond hair back in a bun, with a sporty headband every day. I’d never seen her without lip gloss. If that was the kind of girl Jesse liked, I stood no chance.